By Susanne Skov Diemer
for the 2026 Risky Women Writing Competition, presented in partnership with Ocorian
Color-coded heat maps won’t save you in a crisis. When things break, real risk control lives in human judgment—not an unread binder.
Background
Before I ever sat across a boardroom table, I sat across from a principal whose life depended on a judgment call, not a document. As a security, resilience and intelligence specialist, my job was never to predict a risk on paper. It was to walk a site, read a room, and decide – in real time – whether the person in front of me was safe. No binder ever made that decision. A trained, trusted person did.
Twenty-five years and hundreds of assessments later, for governments, corporations and private families – I have sat in enough boardrooms to notice something the security world would never accept: the corporate world calls a spreadsheet ‘Risk Management’, gives it a color-coded heat map and calls the job done. So, I ran the same assessment on that spreadsheet that would run on a building or a principal. Here is what I found;
Findings
Finding one – static documentation, dynamic threat. A risk register is a snapshot: it records what a threat looked like on the day someone filled in the colour. It does not track how fast the conditions around it have moved since then. In protective work we call this ‘losing the read’ – updating a document is not the same as updating your situational awareness.
I once advised a board that reviewed its country risk register once a year, at the same setting as the budget. Three months later a contested election in one of the their core operation markets triggered curfews and capital controls within seventy-two hours. I flagged the shift the moment it started moving, not at the next scheduled review, and the board authorised an emergency repositioning of people and assets before it made the news. Risk doesn’t wait for the calendar, which is exactly why it can not only be reviewed once a year.
Finding two – controls that live in binders, not in people. Most enterprise controls are policies; a document naming who is responsible if X happens. A real control is a trained person who recognises X happening and knows without consulting the binder, what to do next.
A client third-party risk framework called for an annual supplier audit, all completed and signed off on schedule. Reading shipping data that had nothing to do with the audit cycle, I noticed a key supplier’s ownership had shifted, through a chain of shell entities into a jurisdiction about to face sanctions. I took it to the board directly, months outside the normal reporting rhythm, and we exited the relationship before a regulator or a journalist found it first. The control was compliant. It just wasn’t looking in real time.
Finding three – a vetting theatre. Organisations screen people and vendors against a checklist of red flags rather than building a genuine behavioural read of who is actually standing near the risk. A checklist tells you what someone has done. It rarely tells you what they will do under pressure.
During executive vetting for a multinational, I flagged that a COO candidate’s behavioural assessment showed that he had struggled to hold composure in a previous high-stress incident – as a result his CV and references never surfaced. He was hired anyway: the board weighed his operational record over a single flagged data point. 18-months later in a live crisis, he insisted on a seat in the crisis room and froze at the critical decision point – exactly as the original assessment outcome had predicted. The theatre was not missing a check, its was overriding the one check that actually worked.
Assessed Threat
The real vulnerability is not that companies lack risk frameworks. Its that they have mistaken the framework for the control. A register nobody re-reads under pressure, a policy nobody has rehearsed, a vetting process that stops at the paperwork: each gives the appearance of protection while leaving the organisation exposed exactly where it matters – it’s the moment judgement is required and no document is going to make the call for you.
Recommended counter measures:
- Fund rehearsals, not just documentation. A plan only proves its worth if someone has practised acting before the actual day – its the same logic behind scenario-based crisis leadership training for executives and boards.
- Vet like you mean it. Put a trained, in-person behavioural read ahead of – not instead of – the paperwork, especially for the people closest to your highest value risk.
- Give leadership composure its own line on the risk register, next to the cyber and financial exposure – because the moment the plans runs out it’s where the real exposure lives and right now almost nobody is measuring it.
A fact
None of this is a case against risk registers, controls or governance – they are necessary, and I have built plenty of them myself. It is the case against treating them as sufficient. The best protective work I have ever done did not happen because a document told someone what to do. It happened because a trained person, standing in the right place, made the right call in the three seconds a policy manual doesn’t have time to be consulted.
Enterprise Risk Management would do well to remember what protective security never forgot: the paper was always meant to be a guide for the person – never a substitute for one.
Residual Risk: unchanged, until organisations start funding people the way they fund paperwork.